Can You Freeze Chicken Salad With Mayo?

I love chicken salad, especially when it’s made with mayo. It often makes for a tasty, filling, and convenient meal. But can you freeze chicken salad with mayo?

Well, I’ve never had much luck freezing chicken salad with mayo. It never seems to taste as good as it was before being frozen and unfrozen. After a little research, I learned that the problem ingredient is the mayo! The truth is that mayo does not freeze well. But why is that? Keep reading to find out!

Table Of Contents:

Can You Freeze Chicken Salad With Mayo?

Chicken Salad With Mayo

When properly stored in the freezer, many foods can last a long time and still be good and safe to eat after thawing. Other foods (like mayo) are a little more risky.

If you have extra chicken salad with mayo left over and wish to save some for later, keep in mind that mayonnaise can separate or become watery upon thawing. This can make the taste and texture of the chicken salad unappetizing, so freezing chicken salad with mayo is usually not a good idea.

If you still want to try freezing chicken salad with the mayo already added, make sure you eat it within the next month or two so it doesn’t have a chance to go bad. But even if it is still safe to eat, be warned that it may look or taste a little funky due to separated mayo.

To ensure maximum freshness and quality, you should store the chicken salad in an airtight container. When thawing chicken salad, it’s important to do so in the refrigerator and to consume it within two or three days of thawing.

If you haven’t already added mayo to the other ingredients, you can freeze them without the mayo. Later when you thaw these ingredients, you can mix in some fresh mayo before serving. This trick is not always convenient, but if you can freeze the other ingredients without the mayo, this may keep them fresh a while longer because the mayo would otherwise cause the other ingredients to spoil more quickly even when frozen.

back to menu ↑

What Are The Bad Effects Of Freezing Chicken Salad?

It is not recommended to freeze chicken salad with mayonnaise for a few reasons:

Separation or curdling of the mayonnaise: When mayonnaise is frozen and later thawed, it will separate and become watery. This can negatively affect the texture and flavor of your dish.

Change in texture: The texture of the chicken can change when it is frozen and then thawed. It can become tough, dry, and rubbery, and this can make the chicken salad much less appealing.

Degraded flavors: The flavor of the chicken salad can also change when it is frozen and then thawed. The mayonnaise can become bland or sour, and the other ingredients in the salad may also lose some of their flavour.

Food safety: If the chicken salad is not stored properly or if it’s been thawed and then refrozen, it can increase the risk of foodborne illness. Mayonnaise does not freeze well mainly due to its oil content, and it’s best to avoid freezing foods that contain mayo when possible.

back to menu ↑

Normal Chicken Salad Vs Mayo Chicken Salad

The key difference between mayo chicken salad and other types of chicken salad is the type of dressing or sauce used to bind the other ingredients together. Instead of mayo, chicken salad can be made with yogurt, sour cream, avocado, or oil and vinegar. Chicken salad made from these ingredients has a lighter and tangier flavor, while mayo chicken salad has a creamier and richer flavor due to the use of mayonnaise.

No matter what kind of chicken salad you like most, you probably enjoy having a little bit of dessert after dinner. If you’re still hungry after finishing off your mayo chicken salad, you may want to try some Crumbl cookies.

back to menu ↑

4 Ways To Tell If Chicken Salad Has Gone Bad

Here are some things you can check immediately to see if your chicken salad has gone bad:

• Smell: Fresh chicken salad should have a pleasant and mild aroma. If there is a sour or rancid smell to it, it has probably gone bad.

• Texture: Fresh chicken salad has a smooth and creamy texture. If the texture has become lumpy or slimy, the chicken salad has likely gone bad.

• Appearance: If the chicken salad has changed in color (such as turning gray) or if it has mold growing on it, the chicken salad is no longer safe to eat. Go ahead and throw it away!

• Taste: If you’re still unsure if the chicken salad is fresh, give it a quick taste. If it tastes rancid or sour, you should probably throw it away.

If you are a Hello Fresh subscriber and enjoy chicken salad, you should know that they have a number of delicious chicken salad recipes you can try, including Sonoma chicken salad with pecans, grapes, and garlic croutons.

back to menu ↑


Chicken salad is a quick and easy dish that you can make ahead of time and store in the refrigerator for later enjoyment. It is a great option for busy people who need a quick and nutritious meal on the go. But if you have an extra chicken salad made with mayo and would like to freeze some for later, remember that the oil and egg yolks in mayonnaise make it prone to separation and spoilage when frozen.

If you decide to freeze chicken salad with mayo, make sure you keep it in an airtight container, and don’t leave it in the freezer for longer than a few months.

back to menu ↑

Common FAQs

Can you freeze chicken salad with yogurt?

Yes, you can freeze chicken salad with yogurt, but remember that freezing can cause the yogurt in the chicken salad to separate and become grainy. It will last for a few months in the freezer, but be sure to store it in an airtight container.

back to menu ↑

Is chicken salad with mayo healthy?

Yes and no. Chicken is a good source of lean protein, and veggies like celery and onion can make the dish healthier by adding fiber and nutrients. However, traditional chicken salad with mayo is high in fat and calories. Try substituting regular mayo with a reduced-fat version for a healthier dish.

back to menu ↑

What is the best alternative to mayonnaise?

The best alternative to mayonnaise in your chicken salad will depend on your personal tastes and nutritional needs, but some good alternatives to mayo include Greek yogurt, avocado, olive oil, buttermilk, or hummus. Try these different options to find the ones that work best for you.

While you’re thinking about fun and tasty ingredients you can add to your chicken salad, consider mixing in some fry seasoning, which will give your chicken salad a savory and slightly spicy flavor.

Shanny not only has an exceptional understanding of the foodie mindset and how nutrition works, she has also achieved her Master’s Degree in Education. Outside of her academic achievements, she loves writing food blogs. It's so much more than a list of meals though! Shanny creates helpful cookware guides and delicious recipes that are easy to follow. She does all of this as a food blog writer because she loves it. That's why she spends lots of time testing out different recipes in her own home. She truly is a one-of-a-kind foodie, from her home to yours - with a story to tell, new recipes to indulge in and new tips to tantalize those tastebuds.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply